Works council appeal against Ring reorganisation dismissed: objections belong in the advice itself

On 12 November 2026, the Enterprise Chamber of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal published a decision of 15 October 2026 on the appeal by the works council of Ring of Security B.V., part of the Amazon group since 2018. The works council challenged a reorganisation decision under which 59 positions in the Netherlands lapse. The Enterprise Chamber dismissed the requests. The decision shows how decisive the content of the advice itself is.
Conditionally positive advice, then negative
Ring requested the works council's advice on 3 November 2025. After six consultation meetings, the works council gave positive advice on 14 January 2026 subject to four conditions: a longer notice period, higher compensation under the social plan, a more proactive redeployment process and a positive reference letter. Ring did not meet those conditions, so according to the works council its advice became negative. Ring took the decision on 12 February 2026. On appeal, the works council argued that quantitative and verifiable substantiation was missing, that alternatives had not been sufficiently examined and that Ring had departed from the advice without proper reasons.
What is not in the advice generally does not count
The Enterprise Chamber held that a works council may generally only raise objections it made known in its advice. The employer generally need not take into account objections raised earlier in the process but not maintained in the advice. Exceptions apply to facts the works council did not know or need to know when giving its advice, and to material defects in the request for advice. The objection about missing quantitative information had been raised in November 2025, but was not included in the advice. Other alternatives, such as matching employees in advance to vacancies in Toronto, were not in the advice either, so Ring did not have to take them into account.
Reasons for departing from the advice were sufficient
The redeployment proposal was included in the advice. Ring gave sufficient reasons for not following it: the group's international redeployment policy aims to give all affected employees equal opportunities, without preference for any specific group. Under Article 25(5) of the Dutch Works Councils Act (WOR), the employer must address the works council's arguments specifically. Ring did so for redeployment, the notice period, the reference letter and compensation.
Practical tips
Works councils: state every objection and alternative you wish to maintain explicitly in the advice itself, even if it was discussed earlier.
Employers: address every condition and argument in the advice specifically, point by point, in the decision (Article 25(5) WOR).
Document the consultation process carefully, for example in a Q&A document; information exchanged during the process is taken into account.
Read more on employee participation in our knowledge base. Planning a reorganisation or consultation process? Contact us; we are happy to help.
This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.






