top of page

Advocate General: no whistleblower report established, but an unannounced meeting with a lawyer present was culpable

Writer: Joost van Ladesteijn
Joost van Ladesteijn
11 minutes ago
2 min read

On 19 November 2026 the opinion delivered by Advocate General Van Peursem on 13 November 2026 was published, in a dismissal case between the municipality of Kerkrade and an employee who invoked the Dutch Whistleblowers Protection Act (Wbk) (ECLI:NL:PHR:2026:1096). An opinion is advice to the Supreme Court; the Supreme Court will rule later.

Side work without permission

According to the municipality, the employee, alongside his full-time job of 36 hours a week, worked as a trainee lawyer without the required permission. He was suspended pending the investigation into his side activities. The subdistrict court and the court of appeal dissolved the employment contract on the e-ground (culpable conduct), awarding the statutory transition payment.

No report of a suspected wrongdoing

The employee argued that, before his suspension, he had already reported a suspected financial wrongdoing. After the taking of evidence, the court of appeal found this not proven. Sharing his concerns about a file with the responsible alderman fell, according to the court of appeal, within the performance of his duties and was not regarded as a report. The Advocate General notes that, given the protective nature of the EU Whistleblower Directive, a broad interpretation of the concept of wrongdoing is appropriate, although not every report or communication falls within it. In his view, the court of appeal's finding can stand in cassation.

A meeting with a different agenda

The municipality had invited the employee to a meeting about his reintegration. In that meeting he was confronted with his side work, with the municipality's lawyer present. The court of appeal held that a good employer should not hold such a meeting with an employee unannounced in the presence of a lawyer. That was culpable, but not seriously culpable. In cassation, the employee sought a rule that such a meeting is always seriously culpable. According to the Advocate General, such a 'hard and fast rule' does not fit employment law: whether there is seriously culpable conduct depends on all the circumstances of the case. He advises dismissing both the principal and the cross-appeal in cassation.

Practical tips

  • Announce in advance what a meeting is about and who will attend, so that the employee can prepare and, if necessary, obtain legal assistance.

  • Set out in your HR policy or the employment contract whether and how permission is required for side activities.

  • If the Wbk is invoked, carefully establish whether and when a report of a suspected wrongdoing was made, and record this.

Want to know what this means for your organisation? Please contact us.

This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.

bottom of page