White paper 'Certainty within limits': what can a legislator know in advance about qualifying a working relationship?

On 16 November 2026, our founding partner Joost van Ladesteijn published the white paper 'Zekerheid binnen grenzen. Het werknemersbegrip tussen Den Haag en Luxemburg' (Certainty within limits. The concept of worker between The Hague and Luxembourg). The occasion is the draft Self-Employed Persons Act (Zelfstandigenwet), which promises self-employed persons and their clients more certainty in advance. The white paper examines what a legislator can know in advance about the qualification of a working relationship, and what it cannot.
The promise of the Self-Employed Persons Act
With the draft Act, the Dutch government aims to set clear criteria in advance on how self-employed persons and clients can work together. The proposal uses a self-employment test and a working-relationship test: those who meet both and also work that way should know in advance where they stand. The public consultation ran until 29 October 2026; the intended entry into force is January 2028.
Under current Dutch law, whether an agreement is an employment contract within the meaning of Article 7:610 of the Dutch Civil Code is a matter of interpreting and qualifying the agreement (Supreme Court, 24 March 2023, ECLI:NL:HR:2023:443). That question is answered in light of all the circumstances of the case, including how the parties actually perform the agreement. That cannot be fully fixed in advance.
The Hague and Luxembourg
The white paper adds a second layer: EU law. Where the Court of Justice interprets the concept of worker autonomously, it is not the national legislator that determines who counts as a worker. The outcome of the white paper in one sentence: where EU law defines the concept of worker autonomously, no national instrument can guarantee the correct qualification in advance.
That does not mean certainty is out of reach. According to the white paper, certainty is possible regarding evidence and the public-law consequences.
A living document
Joost is sharing the white paper now because work on the draft Self-Employed Persons Act is in full swing and the paper may be of use in its further development. It is a living document: he will update it when legislation, case law or comments from practice give reason to do so.
Practical tips
Do not expect the Self-Employed Persons Act to guarantee the qualification of the agreement in advance; how the work is actually performed remains relevant.
Record how an assignment is carried out in practice, so that you can demonstrate it later.
Have each engagement of self-employed persons assessed and follow the further development of the Act.
Read more on this topic in our knowledge base under the theme of bogus self-employment: https://www.vertexlegal.nl/kennisbank?thema=schijnzelfstandigheid
Do you engage self-employed persons and want to know where certainty in advance is and is not possible? Please contact us.
This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.







