top of page

Weighing is not counting: six reasoning errors when assessing freelance engagements

Writer: Joost van Ladesteijn
Joost van Ladesteijn
1 day ago
2 min read

On Thursday 12 November, Joost van Ladesteijn spoke at the invitation of Voca at the ZWiZ meeting in Zoetermeer about false self-employment and common reasoning errors in procurement practice. The core message: weighing is not counting. Anyone who adds up circumstances, or treats what is inherent in the work as an indication of employment, is not assessing the legal relationship but the profession.

Interpretation first, then classification

The question is not whether someone 'is' a freelancer or an employee, but whether the contract the parties concluded is an employment contract within the meaning of Article 7:610 of the Dutch Civil Code. First, you establish what the parties agreed (interpretation, under the Haviltex standard). Then you classify those rights and obligations, taking into account all circumstances of the case in their mutual context (Supreme Court 24 March 2023, ECLI:NL:HR:2023:443, Deliveroo). The parties' intentions matter for the interpretation, not for the classification. External entrepreneurship is a fully-fledged factor in that assessment (Supreme Court 21 February 2025, Uber).

Six reasoning errors in procurement practice

  • Giving too much weight to an obligation of best efforts.

  • Counting instead of weighing.

  • Requiring a perfect score on every factor.

  • Looking at what is done rather than how it is done.

  • Anticipating the classification.

  • Equating constraints inherent in the work with employer's authority.

Embedding: is 'an essential part of the business' enough?

Many assessments of freelance relationships state that the work is an essential part of the business and therefore points towards an employment contract. According to the Dutch Tax Administration's own Explanatory Notes (April 2026), a location or time that follows from the nature of the work does 'not automatically' point to an employment contract, with the construction site as an example. Under factor 3 of the same Notes, however, location, working hours and facilities still count. A working document from consultations with the healthcare sector, released under the Open Government Act, states that it must first be established which elements of embedding are 'presumably unavoidable'. The legislator dropped the 'core activities' criterion in 2024, and organisational embedding is deliberately not a criterion in the working-relationship test of the draft Self-Employed Persons Act. Treating the embedding of the work as an indication of employment quickly means assessing the profession instead of the legal relationship.

Practical tips

  • First record what the parties agreed and how this works in practice, and only then classify the relationship.

  • Weigh the factors in their mutual context and separate what follows from the nature of the work or from laws and regulations from authority actually exercised by the client.

  • Give external entrepreneurship full weight in the assessment and document the relevant facts.

More on this topic in our knowledge base: knowledge base on false self-employment. Do you hire freelancers and want to know whether your assessment holds up? Contact us; we are happy to help.

This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.

bottom of page