Wav stoppage warning: scope and impact on third parties must be assessed upfront

On 11 November 2026, the Administrative Jurisdiction Division of the Council of State (Raad van State) ruled on a warning of a preventive work stoppage under Article 17b of the Dutch Foreign Nationals Employment Act (Wav) (ECLI:NL:RVS:2026:6658). According to the Council of State's announcement, the case concerned Uber Portier B.V., which operates an online platform on which consumers order meals and have them delivered. The Minister of Social Affairs and Employment had appealed against a judgment of the Amsterdam District Court of 21 February 2025.
From fines to a warning
The Wav prohibits an employer from having a foreign national perform work in the Netherlands without the required permit (Article 2(1) Wav). After fining the company for violations that, in the Minister's view, it had committed between December 2019 and January 2022, the Minister issued a warning on 19 April 2023. At that time, the fines were not yet final. A warning is the first step: if a further violation occurs, the Minister may order that work be halted for a maximum of three months. The District Court annulled the warning because its proportionality had not been properly reasoned and the economic consequences for third parties had not been visibly taken into account.
A full proportionality test, even for a warning
The Division upheld the District Court's judgment. The Minister had wrongly treated his proportionality assessment as a test against the arbitrariness standard. For a warning, as for a stoppage order, the standard set in the so-called Harderwijk ruling of 2 February 2022 (ECLI:NL:RVS:2022:285) applies. The exact scope of a future violation is not yet known when a warning is issued, but the Division saw no reason why the Minister could not already estimate how extensive a possible stoppage would be. He is also required to make that estimate.
The Minister had not sufficiently shown what a stoppage would mean for the couriers and the restaurants, not even in his statement of defence. He did not address, for example, how long it takes to find other work or the income couriers would lose. The Division pointed the way: the Netherlands Labour Authority can demand information under Article 5:16 of the General Administrative Law Act (Awb), and the company must provide it under Article 5:20 Awb. The Minister may work with scenarios; it is then up to the company to show that they are incorrect. In a later stoppage order, he may depart from the estimated scope, provided he gives reasons.
What does this mean?
A warning is not a mere formality. A company that receives one may expect it to contain a reasoned estimate of the scope of a possible stoppage and of the economic consequences for third parties, such as people working through the platform and business customers. On the other hand, the Labour Authority can request data to make that estimate, and the company must cooperate.
Practical tips
Review any warning under Article 17b Wav straight away for its reasoning: does it estimate the scope of a stoppage and the consequences for third parties?
Respond fully and on time to a request for information from the Labour Authority; your own figures may later help to rebut the Minister's scenarios.
Map out who performs work in your business processes and whether the required permits are in place for foreign nationals, including for work through a platform.
Read more on this topic in our knowledge base, including an earlier ruling on a meal delivery platform as an employer under the Wav. Questions about your own situation? Contact us.
This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.






