The government’s online assessment tool for working relationships does not hold up methodologically

Many clients use the Dutch government’s online tool for assessing working relationships (Webmodule Beoordeling Arbeidsrelatie) to estimate whether an assignment can be performed outside an employment relationship. In ZiPconomy (17 September), Joost van Ladesteijn argues that the tool does not hold up methodologically.
Adding up is not weighing
The tool uses a points model: answers produce fixed scores, and at a certain score a verdict follows. Whatever is not scored is left out of the picture. The Dutch Supreme Court, however, requires a holistic test in which all circumstances of the case are weighed together. A calculation with fixed weights does not do that.
Incomplete and encouraging risk avoidance
The tool is also incomplete: relevant circumstances are not addressed. In practice, it therefore encourages risk-averse behaviour. Clients treat an outcome such as “indication of employment” as a final verdict, while a court weighing all circumstances may reach a different conclusion.
Revision or abolition
Joost therefore calls for a fundamental revision of the tool, or for its abolition.
What this means for clients
Use the tool as an aid at most, not as a legal verdict.
Assess the assignment under Article 7:610 of the Dutch Civil Code and Supreme Court case law, taking all circumstances into account.
Document your assessment for each assignment.
Read the article (in Dutch): ZiPconomy.
This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.







