top of page

Redundancy dismissal fails: employer could not show what the role actually involved

Writer: Joost van Ladesteijn
Joost van Ladesteijn
Nov 6
2 min read

On 5 November 2026 the District Court of The Hague published a decision of the subdistrict court of 13 October 2026 (ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:31947). Shell Global Solutions International B.V. had asked the court to dissolve the employment contract of an R&D specialist because his position had ceased to exist. The court refused.

From the UWV to the subdistrict court

In 2024 the Shell group decided on a global restructuring. As of 1 April 2025 the employee was placed on garden leave with continued pay. The employer applied to the UWV for permission to give notice, but the UWV refused in February 2026. The employer then asked the subdistrict court to dissolve the contract on economic grounds (Article 7:669(3)(a) Dutch Civil Code).

Restrained review, but proof for each position

The court reviews the decision to restructure with restraint: that is primarily a matter for the business. This does not relieve the employer of having to show that this particular employee's position necessarily ceases to exist. That is where the case failed. The employer argued that the work mainly consisted of developing in-house software, which the employee disputed. The job description submitted by the employer turned out to have been drawn up after the fact, to support its position in the UWV procedure. An objective description of the actual work was therefore lacking. Without that basis, the court could not establish that the position had ceased to exist, and it left open whether redeployment was possible.

Redeployment with priority

The court did, however, impose redeployment obligations on the employer, which did not oppose them. Within fourteen days, the employer must invite him to a redeployment meeting and actively guide him towards a suitable position, or one that can be made suitable, within the company or the Shell group. As a redundant employee he may not be treated on an equal footing with internal candidates who are not redundant. The court attached a penalty of € 100 per day, up to a maximum of € 10,000.

Practical tips

  • Before a reorganization, document for each role what work is actually performed, for example through up-to-date job descriptions and input from line managers.

  • A job description written only during the dismissal procedure carries little weight as evidence. Make sure your documentation reflects day-to-day practice.

  • If the UWV or the court refuses dismissal, draw up a concrete redeployment plan and give redundant employees priority for internal vacancies.

Read more on this topic in our knowledge base, including this ruling. Questions about your own situation? Contact us.

This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.

bottom of page