top of page

Option forfeiture clause upheld in redundancy dismissal

Writer: Joost van Ladesteijn
Joost van Ladesteijn
Nov 4
2 min read

On 3 November 2026, the Court of Appeal of 's-Hertogenbosch published a decision of 30 July 2026. After more than thirty years, an employee lost his job in a worldwide reorganisation of the group. The Employee Insurance Agency (UWV) granted permission to give notice on economic grounds. On appeal, the dispute concerned the reorganisation itself, redeployment, the statutory transition payment and his share options.

Organisational reasons: no need to open the books

The employee argued that his department was doing well financially. The court disagreed. The reorganisation was not primarily driven by a poor financial position but by organisational changes: a management layer and the Market Benelux department disappeared, and markets were grouped into regions. Disclosure of the profit and loss account was therefore not required. The employer had explained the need for the reorganisation in detail in its request to the works council and in its application to the UWV. Given his special position, with 'Chinese walls' separating his department from the rest of the business, his role was also not interchangeable.

Redeployment: if you do not apply, it is hard to complain later

All vacancies were published. Affected employees were given at least ten working days to apply with priority, a redeployment interview and a redeployment form. The employee went on holiday right after the explanation and did not apply for any role afterwards either. According to the court, he should have made his interest known immediately on his return. Moreover, it is for the employer, within the limits of good employership, to select the most suitable candidate. The redeployment obligation had not been breached.

Options lapse, even in a no-fault dismissal

Under an LTI plan, the employee held options on shares in the parent company. Under that plan, the options lapsed on termination of the employment contract, without compensation. The subdistrict court had held that refusing to pay out was contrary to good employership. The court of appeal disagreed: the forfeiture clause was validly agreed, and there is no basis for obliging the employer to let the options vest or to compensate for them, even though the end of the employment contract was not the employee's fault. The employee must repay EUR 14,609 gross. Neither the options nor a pension allowance count towards the transition payment. He does receive compensation for untaken holiday, because the employer had not kept holiday records.

Practical tips

  • Set out clearly in a share or option plan what happens on termination of employment, and refer to the plan in the employment contract.

  • Make redeployment visible: publish vacancies, give redundant employees priority and a clear deadline, and record what was discussed with them.

  • Keep holiday records (Article 7:641(2) Dutch Civil Code), including for managers who plan their own leave.

Read more about reorganisations in our knowledge base. Facing a reorganisation or questions about a share or option plan? Get in touch.

This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.

bottom of page