top of page

Mandarin teacher: no reasonable ground for redundancy dismissal

Writer: Joost van Ladesteijn
Joost van Ladesteijn
Nov 3
2 min read

On 3 November 2026, a decision of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal of 20 October 2026 on dismissal for business-economic reasons was published. The court shows that an employer must substantiate the need to eliminate a position in concrete terms: per position, and in light of the overall staffing and the finances.

What happened?

A private international school wanted to eliminate one of its two Mandarin teacher positions due to overstaffing. The UWV refused permission and the subdistrict court rejected termination. The school appealed.

The court's ruling

The court considers that the employer must make it sufficiently plausible that the business-economic circumstances make the chosen measure necessary. The school did not succeed. Total pupil numbers fell by almost twenty percent over six years, but the number of Mandarin pupils remained more or less stable. The school did not show how it had assessed staffing across the school as a whole. The alleged overstaffing was partly the result of its own decision in 2020 to increase the other teacher's working hours from 83 to 100 percent. Nor was there a financial necessity: the school achieves considerable positive results every year.

Without a reasonable ground, the court does not get to the question of redeployment. The school must readmit the teacher to her own position within 48 hours, on pain of a penalty of € 750 gross per day up to a maximum of € 50,000 gross.

What does this mean for employers?

A general decline in turnover or numbers is not enough. The employer must show why this particular position has to go, how the staffing as a whole was assessed and how its own earlier choices fit into that. Read more about where reorganisations go wrong in our VL Focus Reorganisation.

Practical tips

  • Substantiate the need per position with current workload figures, not only with organisation-wide trends.

  • Show how the staffing as a whole was assessed and why alternatives are not sufficient.

  • Take into account your own earlier choices, such as contract extensions, that may explain the alleged overstaffing.

Read more on this topic in our knowledge base, including this ruling. Questions about your own situation? Contact us.

This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.

bottom of page