top of page

Garden leave after a refused dismissal permit: permitted, but not indefinitely

Writer: Joost van Ladesteijn
Joost van Ladesteijn
Oct 20
2 min read

If the UWV refuses a dismissal permit, must the employee return to work? Not automatically, according to a judgment in summary proceedings of the District Court of Limburg (Roermond) of 13 October 2026. But suspension from work on full pay is not an end point either.

The facts

A Project Engineer had been employed since 2017. The employer moved activities, including Project Engineering, to Slovakia and in October 2025 applied for a dismissal permit for, among others, his position. The UWV refused the permit on 13 February 2026. No request for dissolution was filed with the subdistrict court. From 5 May 2026 the employee was released from work on full pay. In summary proceedings he claimed to be reinstated in his work.

The standard: good employership

The court considers that good employership (Article 7:611 of the Dutch Civil Code) means that an employer must in principle allow the employee to perform the agreed work. A departure from this requires a reasonable and compelling reason. The employee's substantial interest in working is weighed against the employer's freedom to organise its business as it sees fit, including a restructuring.

No structural workload left

The employer made such a reason sufficiently plausible. Around 90 percent of the employee's actual work had been moved to sites in Slovakia, China and/or Poland, and the projects he worked on had largely been completed. A full and sufficiently structural workload was lacking. The UWV's refusal does not change this: it only means that the employer may not give notice, which it had not done. The claim is dismissed.

The court does add, for the sake of completeness, that a release from work must serve a purpose and lead somewhere. The employee cannot be kept in uncertainty indefinitely; it is up to the employer to take action.

Practical tips

  • Record why you release an employee from work and substantiate with facts which tasks have structurally disappeared, and when.

  • Link the release to a concrete next step, such as redeployment, a request for dissolution or talks about a settlement agreement.

  • Do not treat a refused dismissal permit as the end of the road: decide in good time which route fits next.

Read more about reorganisation and redundancy in our knowledge base under the theme Reorganisation. Facing a release from work or a reorganisation in your organisation? Get in touch with us.

This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.

bottom of page