Amsterdam Court of Appeal: € 225,000 fair compensation after flawed internal investigation

On 10 November 2026 the Amsterdam Court of Appeal published a decision of 27 October 2026 in a dispute between Lloyds Bank GmbH and its Head of HR, who had worked for the bank since 2008. The decision concerns the requirements for an internal investigation and what an employer must do after the subdistrict court has refused a request to terminate the employment contract.
An investigation without distance
In 2023 the bank had an internal investigation carried out into whether the Head of HR had breached procurement rules and used the director's signature without permission. A more personal question was added later. According to the court, the investigation was neither independent nor careful. The director was involved throughout, information was shared with colleagues and the supervisory board in breach of internal rules, and the employee was only heard after more than a year, without access to her emails and documents.
As a result, the allegations could not be established and the e-ground (culpable conduct) failed. The h-ground did not help either: according to the court, it cannot be used to repair a dismissal that is insufficiently substantiated on another ground.
After the refusal, the door stayed shut
The subdistrict court refused termination in January 2026. The bank then did not allow the employee to return and attached conditions to her return, including a forensic investigation by an external firm. On appeal, the employee accepted termination on the g-ground (disrupted working relationship). Under Article 7:683(5) Dutch Civil Code, the court ruled that the employment contract will end on 1 March 2027.
Seriously culpable conduct by the employer
In addition to the statutory transition payment of over € 56,000 gross, the court awarded fair compensation of € 225,000 gross. It found the bank's conduct seriously culpable, in particular the unreasonable demands placed on the employee's return after the subdistrict court's decision. The employee herself had not acted (seriously) culpably.
Practical tips
Ensure an internal investigation is independent: keep involved managers at a distance and do not share preliminary findings more widely than necessary.
Hear the employee concerned in good time and give access to the relevant emails and documents.
If the court refuses termination, let the employee return and do not impose conditions that make a return impossible in practice.
Read more on this topic in our knowledge base. Questions about your own situation? Contact us.
This blog provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice on a specific situation, please contact us.






